The Frontier Design Benchmark is live.

Read on XLinkedIn

Broomwagon website

15 Outputs168 Votes
Golden

Model outputs

15 models + golden

    How the models rank on this task

    Leaderboard
    Contra LabsFrontier Design Benchmark
    50% · even
    1. Human golden
    2. Claude Sonnet 5.5
    3. Claude Opus 5.5
    4. Kimi K3.1 Pro
    5. Claude Fable 5.2
    6. GPT-6 Astra
    7. GPT-6.1 Sol
    8. Gemini 4 Carbon
    9. Muse Wonder
    10. Kimi K3
    11. GLM-5.3 Prime
    12. Qwen3.8 Max
    13. Gemini 4 Argon
    14. Grok 4.7
    15. Muse Spark 1.3
    16. DeepSeek V4 Pro

    Quality report

    How we score
    Rubric score85/100
    AI grade51%
    AI slop43/100
    D1.1 Focal point & importance-to-prominence mapping: PassD1.2 Prominence of primary actions & controls: PassD1.3 Competing elements & distraction: PassD4.1 Layout structure & grid: PassD4.2 Alignment & placement: PassD4.3 Spacing & padding: MajorD4.4 Density & white space: PassD4.5 Scale & proportion of elements: PassD4.6 Section order & narrative flow: PassD5.2 Grouping & separation: PassStructureStructureD2.3 Typeface choice & pairing: MinorD2.4 Type scale & hierarchy: PassD2.5 Typesetting detail: PassD3.1 Palette choice & harmony: PassD3.2 Colour discipline & meaning: PassD6.1 Consistency of the visual system (incl. monotony vs variety): PassD6.3 Restraint & purposefulness of elements: PassD6.4 Shadows, textures & decorative effects: PassD6.5 Rendering integrity (overlap, clipping, cropping): PassD6.6 Craft finish & refinement: PassD7.1 Relevance & integration of imagery: MajorD7.2 Quality & craft of images, illustrations & graphics: MinorD7.3 Icon clarity & recognisability: PassD7.4 Charts, tables & data display: PassD7.5 Logo & mark craft: PassD10.1 Fit to brand, product, audience & context: PassVisual craftVisual craftD8.1 Presence & placement of expected controls: PassD8.2 Interactive cues & state clarity: PassD9.1 Copy quality, tone & correctness: PassD9.2 Message clarity, ease of understanding & information sufficiency: PassD9.3 Text volume & concision: PassD9.4 Content credibility & factual coherence: PassD11.1 Colour contrast (text, icons & key elements): PassD11.2 Readable text size: PassD11.3 Touch target size & spacing: MajorContent & useContent & use
    85Rubric score
    35 aspects30 pass2 minor3 major

    Prompt

    # Broomwagon Build Broomwagon, a web app that helps small bicycle-repair businesses create, manage and publish a clear digital service menu without technical skills. Workshop owners should be able to launch their menu quickly and update it from a dashboard. Deliver these pages and functions: 1. Landing page: introduce the product and drive sign-up with a value proposition, feature overview, pricing preview and call-to-action buttons. 2. Authentication: support sign-up, log-in and passwordless email access. 3. Onboarding: guide first-time setup of the service-menu language, business information, working hours, contact details and gallery. 4. Dashboard: make this the main entry point after onboarding. Show publishing status, service-menu access, a preview link, the public URL and plan status. 5. Service-menu editor: let owners create, edit, delete and reorder categories and service items. 6. Item/category management: edit category names, service names, descriptions, prices, photos and visibility. 7. Gallery: upload, remove and manage service or workshop images. 8. Business settings: manage the workshop name, description, address, currency and other core service-menu information. 9. Working hours: set opening hours for each day and mark closed days. 10. Contact details: manage the phone number, social links and other contact information shown on the public service menu. 11. Preview: review the service menu in desktop and mobile layouts before publishing. 12. Public service-menu page: publish a customer-facing menu containing categories, services, prices, photos, business information, working hours and contacts.

    The rest of the brief isn’t published. Contact us to learn more

    Input files

    1 file came with the brief. They aren’t published. Contact us to learn more

      Metadata

      Kind of work
      A web app where bike repair workshops publish their service menu
      Category
      Website
      Deliverable
      A working website · 390, 768 and 1440 px
      Brief
      Contra’s marketplace, the client renamed
      Client
      Broomwagon
      Golden
      Broomwagon · Service menus for bike workshops. Made by a designer
      Evaluation
      168 counted blind votes by 18 reviewers
      Sign inGet in touch